When Healthy Becomes Harmful: Understanding Orthorexia

Orthorexia usually develops out of good intentions: a desire to eat well and feel healthy. But under certain pressures — internal and external — that desire can become rigid, anxious, and controlling.
Magnolia Creek - Featured Image - Orthorexia

Orthorexia nervosa, sometimes called simply orthorexia, is more than just carefully evaluating and selecting the types of food you consume. It’s an increasingly recognized pattern of obsessive thinking around the purity and quality of food. And it can quietly take over a person’s life.

Orthorexia is different from other eating disorders because it is driven by a generally positive desire: to eat more healthfully. Over time, however, those seemingly positive intentions can morph into behaviors and feelings that are compulsive, rigid, and ultimately, harmful.

What is Orthorexia?

Dr. Steven Bratman coined the term orthorexia nervosa in 1997 to describe a pattern of behavior marked by an excessive fixation on eating foods that one considers “healthy” or “pure.” In his view, orthorexia is not just a strong preference for nutritious food; what makes it pathological is when that preference becomes rigid, causes distress, and begins to impair one’s life and health (Bratman, 1997).

Orthorexia is a paradoxical condition because it begins with a sincere desire to improve health, yet the obsessive pursuit of “perfect” eating eventually undermines both mental and physical well-being. What starts as mindful nutrition hardens into an obsession with labeling foods as strictly “good” or “bad,” “pure” or “toxic.” This black-and-white thinking drives the elimination of entire food groups or ingredients, often without medical necessity and at the expense of nutrients that are necessary to health and function. 

Social connections shrink, too. Every day eating situations (dinner at a restaurant, home-cooked meals with friends or family) feel threatening rather than enjoyable — not being able to verify and control how food is sourced and prepared is a dealbreaker for virtually every social situation. Eating outside a controlled environment triggers anxiety, worry, and fear, so it feels easier to withdraw than risk “slipping up.”

The paradox in orthorexia is stark — in striving to become healthier, a person with orthorexia may end up less nourished, more isolated, and burdened with greater psychological distress.

Is orthorexia an eating disorder?

Orthorexia is widely regarded as an emerging eating disorder, though it is not yet an official diagnosis in the DSM-5 (the psychiatric manual used for classification).

That said, clinicians and researchers increasingly consider it part of the eating disorder spectrum because it shares many of the same hallmarks:

  • Rigid food rules and an obsessive preoccupation with eating only foods perceived as “pure” or “healthy.”

  • Emotional distress when those rules are broken, often resulting in guilt, shame, or anxiety.

  • Physical risks such as nutrient deficiencies and unintentional malnutrition when major food groups are eliminated.

  • Social impairment, including withdrawal from meals with friends and avoidance of restaurants or situations where food can’t be controlled.

The main reason orthorexia isn’t recognized as an official diagnosis yet is that experts don’t fully agree on how to define and measure it. Some screening tools do a good job of identifying truly harmful patterns, while others risk confusing committed healthy eating with a disorder. Until researchers can establish clear, consistent criteria that work across different groups of individuals, orthorexia is unlikely to be added to psychiatric diagnostic manuals.

Signs + Symptoms

While the desire to eat well is not harmful in itself, orthorexia becomes concerning when it leads to anxiety, guilt, and life disruptions. Researchers and clinicians point to several common symptoms that help distinguish orthorexia from balanced healthy eating:

  • Obsessive focus on the quality and purity of food, rather than quantity.

  • Strict avoidance of foods considered “unhealthy,” “processed,” or “impure.”

  • Intense anxiety, guilt, or shame when food rules are broken.

  • Excessive time spent researching, planning, or preparing “acceptable” meals.

  • Rigid rules or rituals around eating and food preparation.

  • Avoidance of social events, restaurants, or situations involving food not under personal control.

  • Nutritional deficiencies or unintentional weight loss due to restricted food variety.

  • A sense of self-worth or moral identity tied to eating “correctly.”

Recognizing these signs is not about labeling someone a fanatic or passing judgment on their eating habits. It’s about noticing when the pursuit of health has shifted into something rigid, isolating, or harmful. If food choices are causing distress, interfering with relationships, or narrowing a person’s life instead of enriching it, they may be struggling with disordered eating. 

Causes + Risk Factors

Orthorexia doesn’t have a single cause. Like most eating disorders, it develops through a mix of psychological, cultural, and biological influences that combine in unique ways across different people.

Some of the most common risk factors include: 

  • Personality traits. People who are perfectionistic, anxious, or highly self-disciplined may be more vulnerable to rigid rules around food.

  • Desire for control. Food choices can become a way to manage uncertainty, stress, or emotional discomfort by creating strict boundaries that feel safe.

  • Cultural influences. In a society that glorifies “clean eating,” wellness trends, and “detox” lifestyles, it can feel virtuous to cut out more and more foods deemed “toxic” or “impure”—even when doing so is harmful to one’s health or causes strain in relationships.

  • Social media + influencer culture. Constant exposure to idealized images of health and wellness online can amplify fears of food-related health issues and reinforce the idea that healthy eating is a moral issue.

  • Overlap with other conditions. Orthorexia often shares roots with obsessive-compulsive tendencies and with other eating disorders, such as anorexia nervosa.

  • Biological vulnerabilities. While research is still emerging, studies suggest that genetics and neurobiology — particularly differences in reward pathways and anxiety regulation — may play a role, similar to other eating disorders.

Healing from Orthorexia: Finding Balance + Joy in Food

Because orthorexia is rooted in rigid rules and anxiety about food purity, treatment and recovery often focus on rebuilding flexibility, trust, and self-compassion.

If you or someone you love is struggling with orthorexia, there are supportive steps you can take to heal:

  • Professional guidance. Working with an eating disorder-informed therapist, dietitian, or treatment team helps untangle the obsessive thought patterns and restore balance. Therapy approaches like cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) or acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) are often used to challenge rigid beliefs and reduce anxiety around food.

  • Gradual exposure to flexibility. Recovery isn’t about swinging from extreme restriction to eating everything at once — it’s about slowly reintroducing foods without fear, learning that eating something “imperfect” won’t harm health.

  • Addressing underlying anxiety. Orthorexia is often fueled by perfectionism or the need for control. Working through these traits can reduce the grip food rules have on daily life.

  • Reframing health. Healing means recognizing that true health is not found in perfection, but in balance — eating a wide variety of foods, enjoying social connections, and supporting mental as well as physical well-being.

  • Rebuilding joy + connection. Sharing meals with friends, trying new foods, and embracing flexibility help restore the social and emotional aspects of eating that orthorexia often erodes.

At its heart, recovery is about reclaiming freedom and balance. It’s learning that well-being isn’t measured by the purity or strictness of a diet but by the ability to eat with ease, connect with others, and live fully without food rules and rituals taking center stage.

References

  • Bratman, S. (1997). Health food junkies: Overcoming the obsession with healthful eating. New York: Broadway Books.

If you want to learn more about eating disorder treatment at Magnolia Creek, explore our admissions page or call us today.

Navigation

More Resources

Looking to learn more? Explore related posts, resources, tools, and support from Magnolia Creek below.

Related posts

Sully, CGCA

Therapeutic Facility Dog

Sully is Magnolia Creek’s beloved therapeutic facility dog in training. A mini-Australian labradoodle, he’s undergoing socialization, desensitization, and obedience training as he works toward earning his Canine Good Citizen Award. He participates in individual and group sessions and is known for his playful high-fives and calming presence. Sully brings comfort, joy, and a sense of home to the residential setting, helping clients feel more at ease throughout their treatment experience.

Anna Tamburello, M.Ed., ALC, MT-BC

Primary Therapist

Anna Tamburello serves as a primary therapist at Magnolia Creek, where she combines evidence-based techniques with creative approaches to support client recovery. She earned her master’s in clinical mental health counseling from Auburn University and holds a bachelor’s in music therapy from Appalachian State University.

A board-certified music therapist, Anna integrates music therapy into treatment programming and is the proud handler of Sully, Magnolia Creek’s therapeutic facility dog. She is passionate about empowering individuals on their recovery journeys and believes in meeting clients with compassion, creativity, and care.

Jenna Stanley

Teen Program Administrator

Jenna Stanley serves as the teen program administrator, overseeing clients’ continued education during their treatment. She holds bachelor’s degrees in psychology, history, and education from Samford University. She is passionate about helping clients discover their strengths and reach their full potential in the classroom.

At Magnolia Creek, Jenna fosters a warm and supportive learning environment tailored to each client’s individual goals. Her academic interests include social-emotional learning, Greek mythology, Feudal Japan, neuroscience, and civics. Outside of work, she enjoys reading, spending time with loved ones, and working on puzzles.

Kelsey Byrd

Family Therapist

Kelsey Byrd serves as a family therapist at Magnolia Creek. She earned her bachelor’s degree in human services with a minor in nutrition from Troy University and her master’s in clinical mental health counseling from Jacksonville State University. During her graduate internship at Magnolia Creek, Kelsey confirmed her passion for supporting individuals with eating disorders.

She utilizes a range of treatment modalities, including motivational interviewing, cognitive behavioral therapy, experiential family therapy, and the Gottman Method. Kelsey believes that strong teamwork within the family system is essential to lasting recovery.

Clif Holt

Chef

Chef Clif Holt brings over 25 years of experience as a chef, caterer, restaurateur, and culinary instructor. His philosophy centers on local, sustainable, and healthy eating, combining nutrition with flavor and creativity.

He is passionate about using food as both nourishment and art, and his favorite aspect of culinary work is empowering others. Chef Clif enjoys teaching individuals the skills and confidence they need to feel comfortable in the kitchen — encouraging them to create and prepare meals of their own.

Taylor Helms

Alum Relations Coordinator

As the alum relations coordinator at Magnolia Creek, Taylor Helms is passionate about building a safe, supportive community for clients after residential treatment. She earned a bachelor’s degree in exercise and nutrition science from the University of Montevallo in 2021 and joined Magnolia Creek in 2022 as a recovery care specialist, earning Tier II status.

In her current role, Taylor leads weekly support groups for alums and their families, fostering recovery-focused conversations and connections. She believes in the power of community and is dedicated to encouraging and uplifting others as they work toward their recovery goals.

Courtney Malbrough

Recovery Care Specialist Supervisor

Courtney Malbrough holds a bachelor’s degree in criminal justice and sociology with a minor in psychology. She previously served as a mental health specialist and assistant supervisor at the Louisiana Methodist Children’s Home. In this residential treatment center, she developed a deep passion for mental health care. That passion continues at Magnolia Creek, where she is dedicated to supporting clients on their journey to recovery from eating disorders.

As the Recovery Care Specialist Supervisor, Courtney oversees the residential department to ensure the well-trained team delivers high-quality, compassionate care. She also provides leadership for the residential living and learning experience, helping to create a structured, supportive environment that fosters healing.

Heath Hagood

Facilities Manager

Heath Hagood brings over 20 years of experience in the home improvement industry and more than 13 years in lawn maintenance to his role at Magnolia Creek. With 36 scenic acres to care for, he utilizes his skills to maintain a peaceful and welcoming environment that supports healing and recovery.

Heath enjoys using his expertise to help others and finds fulfillment in contributing to a space that promotes mental health and well-being. Outside of work, he loves spending time outdoors with his family.

Kayla Harvey

Assistant Director of Admissions

Kayla Harvey serves as the Assistant Director of Eating Disorder Admissions, bringing 10 years of social work experience to her role. She began her career in mental health, working with adolescents and adults diagnosed with co-occurring disorders, and previously directed a foster care agency in Anderson, Indiana.

Kayla holds a bachelor’s degree in social work from Ball State University, a master’s degree in human services from Southeastern University, and a master’s degree in healthcare administration from Walden University.

Kayla’s lifelong passion for helping others is evident in her compassionate approach and commitment to each client and family she supports. In her free time, she enjoys being with her husband, family, and two dogs.

Rachel Cannon, MS, LMFT

PHP Coordinator + Therapist

Rachel Cannon serves as the PHP coordinator and a primary therapist at Magnolia Creek. In her coordinator role, she oversees the daily clinical and administrative operations of the partial hospitalization program (PHP) and collaborates across disciplines to support seamless client transitions.

As a primary therapist, Rachel works individually with clients to explore negative thought patterns, strengthen self-worth, and support lasting recovery. She draws from evidence-based approaches, including cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and dialectical behavior therapy (DBT).

Rachel has experience treating individuals with substance use disorders, anxiety, depression, grief, and relational challenges. She holds bachelor’s and master’s degrees in human development and family studies, with a specialization in marriage and family therapy, both from the University of Alabama.

Kelly Moore

Therapist

Kelly Moore is an individual therapist at Magnolia Creek. She earned a bachelor’s degree in psychology with a minor in human services from the University of Montevallo and a master’s degree in social work from the University of Alabama.

With over five years of experience in mental health, Kelly has worked in both acute hospital and residential settings with adults and adolescents (ages 11–17). She has treated clients facing impulse control issues, low self-esteem, anxiety, depression, hallucinations, delusions, and co-occurring disorders.

Kelly takes an integrative approach to therapy, drawing from cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), mindfulness, motivational interviewing, and psychodynamic therapy to best support each client’s needs.

Samantha Patterson, MS

Primary Therapist

Samantha holds an Advanced Alcohol and Drug Counselor (AADC) certification and has served as clinical director at both The Phoenix House and Bessemer Behavioral Health. Since joining Magnolia Creek, she has earned her EMDR certification and provides trauma-specific therapy.

Samantha Patterson is an individual therapist specializing in co-occurring disorders, including substance use and eating disorders. She earned her master’s degree in social work from the University of Alabama in 2015 and began her career in substance abuse treatment across Alabama.

In addition to her clinical work, Samantha serves on the board of directors for the Alabama School of Alcohol and Drug Studies (ASADS), where she helps advance education and standards in the field of addiction studies.

Janifer Stallworth, MS, NCC

Lead Therapist

Janifer Stallworth serves as a family therapist at Magnolia Creek. She earned a bachelor’s degree in psychology from the University of Alabama at Birmingham and a master’s degree in clinical mental health counseling from Argosy University in Atlanta.

Janifer draws from a range of modalities in her work, including cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), and experiential family therapy. She has experience supporting clients with addiction, low self-esteem, anxiety, depression, relationship challenges, and co-occurring disorders.

As both a therapist and a mother, Janifer understands the vital role families play in the healing process. She is passionate about helping individuals and their loved ones strengthen connection, communication, and resilience on the path to recovery.

Alex Aerni, MS, RD, LD

Registered Dietitian

Alex Aerni discovered her passion for nutrition in high school and pursued both her undergraduate and graduate degrees in nutrition and dietetics at Samford University.

During her dietetic internship, Alex completed a rotation at Magnolia Creek, where she developed a deep interest in nutrition counseling and reaffirmed her commitment to helping individuals in recovery.

In her work with clients, Alex uses motivational interviewing and intuitive eating principles to support lasting change and promote a healthier relationship with food. She is dedicated to creating a safe, collaborative space where clients feel empowered on their recovery journey.

Terrica Vincent, CRNP

Nurse Practitioner

Terrica Vincent is a board-certified family nurse practitioner at Magnolia Creek, where she provides medical management and support to clients in treatment.

She began her nursing education at Central Alabama Community College, where she earned an associate’s degree in nursing. She went on to complete her bachelor’s in nursing at Jacksonville State University and a master’s in nursing from the University of Alabama.

Terrica received national board certification as a family nurse practitioner from the American Nurses Credentialing Center in 2018. She brings a compassionate and patient-centered approach to care and is committed to supporting clients on their recovery journey.

Outside of work, Terrica enjoys spending time with her husband and their four children.

Dr. Danielle Hagood

Clinical Director

Dr. Danielle Hagood is a licensed psychologist specializing in eating disorder treatment since 2005. She holds a bachelor’s and master’s degree in counseling psychology from the University of Pittsburgh and a doctorate in clinical psychology from the American School of Psychology.

Before joining Magnolia Creek, Dr. Hagood served as the clinical director of a partial hospitalization program, where she developed programming, provided clinical supervision, led therapy groups, and ensured adherence to quality standards for accreditation and licensing.

Her clinical expertise includes cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), and family systems work. Passionate about helping individuals grow and heal, she is particularly dedicated to educating and reaching out to those affected by eating disorders. Dr. Hagood enjoys creating connections in the community and empowering clients through evidence-based, compassionate care.

Morgan Mason RDN, LDN

Director of Nutrition Services

As Director of Nutrition Services at Magnolia Creek, Morgan Mason oversees the whole food and nutrition program. A registered dietitian nutritionist with over 14 years of experience, she applies evidence-based practices to support clients in their recovery. She is a member of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and is certified through the Commission on Dietetic Registration.

Morgan’s personal experience with an eating disorder fuels her passion for helping others heal. She believes in every person’s capacity for growth and transformation. She earned her bachelor’s degree in nutrition and dietetics from Auburn University and completed her dietetic internship and graduate studies at Mississippi State University.

In her spare time, Morgan enjoys traveling, hiking, and playing tennis. She also cherishes quality time with friends and family.

Alycia Aldieri

AVP of Admissions

As AVP of Eating Disorder Admissions, Alycia Aldieri partners with the clinical partnership team to ensure a responsive, compassionate, and seamless admissions experience. She brings extensive experience working with adults and adolescents with co-occurring disorders, primarily in residential treatment settings.

Alycia holds a master’s degree in clinical psychology from Benedictine University and a bachelor’s degree in music therapy from East Carolina University, where she received classical vocal training. Clinical experience, spiritual beliefs, and 12-step principles shape her therapeutic and professional approach.

Alycia is deeply committed to supporting individuals and families with integrity, compassion, and ethics. She believes that recovery is possible for anyone willing to pursue it — and that living a life of recovery is worth the effort.

Her greatest fulfillment comes from being of service to others, and she’s dedicated to guiding each client and family through the admissions process with clarity, care, and hope.

Tammy Beasley, MS, RDN, CEDS-C

National Director of Nutrition Programming

With over 35 years of experience as a registered dietitian, Tammy Beasley has dedicated her career to advancing the recovery from eating disorders. She was the first registered dietitian nutritionist (RDN) to earn the Certified Eating Disorder Specialist (CEDS) credential through the International Association of Eating Disorder Professionals (IAEDP) in 1993. She later served as certification director from 2013 to 2017, helping to secure CEDS approval for dietitians.

Tammy co-authored the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics’ Standards of Practice for Registered Dietitians treating eating disorders and has developed innovative nutrition programs nationwide. She also mentors clinicians, serves as a media resource, and operates a private practice supporting individuals and organizations.

Tammy’s core principle guides her work: “Do no shame.” She is passionate about helping clients and providers embrace the possibility of full recovery with compassion, dignity, and evidence-based care.

Dr. Tom Scales

Medical Director

Dr. Tom Scales serves as the Network Medical Director for Odyssey Behavioral Healthcare’s Eating Disorder Network, including Magnolia Creek. In this role, he provides psychiatric and medical care to clients and supports clinical excellence across the network. He is board-certified in internal medicine, psychiatry, neurology, and addiction medicine.

Dr. Scales earned his undergraduate degree from Wheaton College and completed medical school at the University of Tennessee in Memphis. He went on to complete a combined internal medicine and psychiatry residency at Rush Presbyterian St. Luke’s Medical Center in Chicago.

Passionate about eating disorder treatment, Dr. Scales has delivered numerous community presentations and media appearances on the topic. He also hosted a weekly live web radio show, Understanding Eating Disorders, on VoiceAmerica Health and Wellness, featuring professionals and individuals with lived experience. And, most importantly, he is a devoted husband and proud father of two.

Lindsay Curlee

Executive Director

As executive director at Magnolia Creek, Lindsay Curlee oversees administrative, operational, and clinical services to ensure the delivery of effective, compassionate care. She leads the team in upholding core principles that promote sustainable, high-quality treatment outcomes.

Lindsay holds a master’s degree in clinical psychology from Valdosta State University, along with bachelor’s degrees in psychology and criminology from Valdosta State and Florida State University, respectively. With over 22 years of behavioral health experience, she has over 15 years of experience in direct clinical care and served 6 years as program coordinator at the Pride Institute in Fort Lauderdale, served as Director of Admissions at the Apalachee Center and served as utilization review coordinator at Magnolia Creek.   

Lindsay is passionate about guiding clients and families toward lasting recovery and is always available to those seeking admission. In her free time, Lindsay enjoys spending quality time with her spouse and their 4 children.

Stefan Glamp

National Director of Alum Services

Stefan Glamp leads the development of the alum community across Odyssey Behavioral Healthcare’s facilities, supporting lasting recovery through structured and compassionate post-treatment engagement. His approach ensures clients remain connected and supported after discharge, helping sustain long-term treatment outcomes.

With extensive experience building and directing alum programs in both addiction and mental health settings, Stefan specializes in meeting individuals where they are in their recovery journey. He also cultivates meaningful community partnerships to extend support beyond the treatment setting. Stefan is deeply committed to the belief that long-term recovery is not only possible — but achievable for all.

Chrissy Hall, LCSW

Group Chief Executive Officer

As Group CEO, Chrissy Hall is responsible for the overall operations, executive leadership team, and delivery of clinical services at Magnolia Creek. She began her career over 25 years ago in the behavioral healthcare field as a direct care staff member. Her experience is primarily in executive leadership positions, serving residential treatment centers, freestanding acute care hospitals, outpatient centers, and military treatment programs, with a focus on clinical and business development.

Chrissy’s areas of expertise include overseeing quality and compliance for startups, clinical best practices, staff education, and program development. She is passionate about leading teams to provide the highest quality of care in safe, therapeutic environments. She received her MSW from Virginia Commonwealth University and is currently licensed as a clinical social worker.

Chrissy is married and has two sons, ages 17 and 20. During her free time, she enjoys going to her sons’ baseball games and traveling.